575 Henry Street, New York, NY
(718) 858-4086 serving: Carroll Gardens

Sidewalk Score: 8 out of 10
Location, Location, Location:


Restaurants, Cash,

The Low Down


The Extras: Lest you stop at the pie, know that an incredibly mild ricotta stuffs the calzone, made with the same thin crust as the pizza.

Rants, Raves & Reviews

by at Gayot

The best pizza in New York? Some discriminating eaters think so and we're inclined to agree. This Carroll Gardens eatery isn't your average pizza joint. For starters, the candlelit interior gives off a chic vibe. There's also no menu. The…
Read More

Awesome, pricey though
By Francy at Menuism

The ambience here is great. We had a simple basil and cheese pie that cost us around $30 which was slightly... Read More

A Slice of Heaven
By astridplt at Citysearch

If you want to go to heaven minus the dying part, go to Lucali. This pizza lover’s paradise is magical. The pie is thin and crunchy at the c... Read More

Rude, rude, rude, not good!
By ilovenewuork at Citysearch

I wouldn't wish this on anyone, so many better places to eat in Brooklyn and who needs the hassle. I wouldn't eat there again if they paid me. If I... Read More

food decent, wait staff could be better, wait is horrendous
By mmmyum at Citysearch

Thought it'd be a pleasant pizza eating experience so thought we'd check it out-- the wait absolutely killed it. We were told (by a could-be-frien... Read More

Wonderful food and atmosphere
By brooklynjoc at Citysearch

incredible pizza and wonderful spot to dine! if you come on the weekend, be prepared to wait! it's generally better (if you can) to come early on a... Read More