The Low Down
Know Before You Go: The oven runs hot and cooks pies quickly. Expect to chow 5-10 minutes after ordering depending on how busy the place is.
Where to Sit: About that hot oven, the seats near the rear can get a little toasty. Opt for one of the window seats if given the choice.
Rants, Raves & Reviews
by at Gayot
Based on the classic Neapolitan thin-style pizza (with an East Coast spin), the 14-inch pies at Coalfire can almost be called "light." In other words, you won't need a napkin to soak up any excess grease, and you won't walk away feelingâ¦
Windy City Pizza Club
By WindyCityPizzaClub at Citysearch
I went to Coalfire Pizza along with the Windy City Pizza Club. I had read reviews from Chicago Magazine before coming on Sunday night and those re... Read More
By Laura B at Insider Pages
I come here before going to some Blackhawk games. The pizza is delicious and well worth a visit. The pizza is cooked at high temps and get the do... Read More
By Nora S at Insider Pages
Coalfire makes an excellent pizza. It tastes fresh and the ingredients are top notch. It's a great place to stop before a Bulls/Hawks game...just... Read More
By Nicki S at Insider Pages
This is some of the best pizza in Chicago (where thin crust pizza is for some reason always cut in squares). This pizza is thankfully cut in trian... Read More
The best traditional pizza in Chicago.......
By PattyOfurniture at Citysearch
This place has undoubtedly the best thin curst pizza in Chicago. The calzones are so-so, but the pizza's the best! Read More