One if by Land, Two if by Sea

One if by Land, Two if by Sea

"New York's Premier Destination for Romance"

17 Barrow St, New York, NY
(212) 255-8649 serving: Downtown, West Village
open:Dinner Hours begin at 5:30 each evening. We take our last reservations at 10 pm on weeknights and 11:15 on Friday and Saturdays Sunday Brunch from 11:30 am to 2:00 pm

Sidewalk Score: 9 out of 10
Location, Location, Location:


Restaurants, New American, Seafood, $$$$, Brunch, Date Spot, Fine Dining, Fireplace, Historic Setting, Notable Wine List, Private Parties, Prix Fixe Menu, Romantic Dining, Special Occasion Dining, American Express Accepted, Diners Club Accepted, Discover Accepted, Mastercard Accepted, Visa Accepted,

The Low Down


The Extras: Popping the question? Call ahead: Waiters are famous for accommodating ring-bearing requests.

What to Drink: Cocktails and wines by the glass are pricy, but pours are generous. The wine list features a reasonably priced international mix: Estancia Cabernet (Napa, $40) is an oaky partner for the Wellington. Fantastic dessert wines, like late-harvest primitivo, pair perfectly with the chocolate-heavy dessert list.

Know Before You Go: The three- and six-course tastings are great values. Let the server up-charge you into the paired wine flight.

Rants, Raves & Reviews

by at Gayot

Some things do get better with time and age, and this Greenwich Village landmark known for its romantic atmosphere is one of them. Set in an eighteenth-century carriage house once owned by Aaron Burr, the bi-level dining room is splendid…
Read More

By Bruce G at Insider Pages

Just satisfied with this place.\r Nice place and nice food. Read More

Perfect for a romantic date...
By Terrence H at Insider Pages

I have to agree that the portions are small, but if you are there on a date, who wants to gorge themselves? It provides a romantic setting(I propos... Read More

Let down.....
By Wendy F at Insider Pages

the food portions are really small for the amount your paying for it, you'll have to spend at least 50 bucks to get full. I could of went to Burger... Read More

The Most Romantic Restaurant in NYC
By XiaoGou at Menuism

Very good quality food. Superb service. In one of the most gorgeous rooms in NYC. They bend over backwards... Read More

My favorite
By Karla T at Insider Pages

I live in Philadelphia and I love this restaurant. It is romantic and the food is excellent! The beef wellington is amazing! I heard about this pla... Read More